Skip to main content

What is the best alternative to a PEO?

The best PEO alternative keeps you the only employer.

The best alternative to a PEO gives you real HR and payroll help without co-employment, per-employee fees or moving onto someone else's benefit plans. King & Co. works inside your own payroll system and alongside your broker, so you keep your company, your provider and your plans. Hands-on work is billed by the hour, and a quiet month has no hourly bill.

  • Employers leaving a PEO
  • Teams that outgrew per-employee fees
  • Growing and multi-state companies

Updated November 7, 2026 · Josh King, Managing Partner. See all guides

What to look for

What separates the best from the rest.

Use these points to judge any provider, including us. Under each one is how we handle it.

No co-employment

With a PEO, it becomes the co-employer of your staff for payroll, tax and benefits purposes. Many owners want to stay the only employer.

How King & Co. does it: We never become your employer of record. You employ your people, and we work alongside your team.

Your plans and your payroll stay yours

A PEO usually moves you onto its payroll platform and its benefit plans. Leaving later means moving everything again.

How King & Co. does it: We work in the payroll system you already use, from ADP and Paychex to Gusto and QuickBooks, and with your own broker on benefits.

Cost that follows the work

PEO fees are charged per employee every month, so the bill grows with headcount whether you needed help or not.

How King & Co. does it: Hands-on work is billed hourly with no monthly minimum. Optional tools like the employee help desk are a flat fee under $150 a month, only if you want them.

A person who knows you

PEO support usually runs through a service center and a ticket queue.

How King & Co. does it: You get a dedicated HR specialist with a backup team, and owners and managers can call or text nights and weekends.

Help on the hard calls

PEOs cover administration well. Terminations, investigations, handbooks and manager coaching often need more attention.

How King & Co. does it: Employee relations, compliance, handbooks, recruiting and leave management are all part of what we do, on site across New England and New York when it helps.

Your options

The real options, side by side.

Every option below is the right answer for someone. Here is who each one fits.

OptionBest forWatch for
King & Co. HR and payroll supportEmployers who want hands-on HR and payroll help, no co-employment, and their own systems and plans, billed by the hour.We are not an insurance pool. Benefit pricing comes from your own broker and carriers, not a PEO's group plan.
Staying with a PEOVery small teams that want payroll, benefits and HR bundled and are comfortable with co-employment.Per-employee fees every month, annual agreements, and a benefits transition if you leave.
Payroll software plus a benefits brokerOwners who run payroll themselves and only need help placing benefit plans.Nobody owns HR. Handbooks, hard conversations and compliance land on the owner or office manager.
A typical HR retainer firmCompanies that want a fixed monthly HR budget and use their hours every month.The same bill in a quiet month, often an hours cap, and six to twelve month terms.
A full-time HR hireLarger employers with full-time HR work every week.Salary, benefits and recruiting cost, plus no backup when that person is out.

Terms vary by provider. These reflect common arrangements, not any one company.

By company size

The best fit changes as you grow.

Small business (under 50)

A PEO can make sense for a very small team that wants big-company benefit pricing. Once you want your own plans, your own payroll system or real HR help, an hourly partner usually costs less in a normal month.

Mid-size (50 to 500)

Per-employee fees add up fast as you hire. This is where many companies leave a PEO, set up their own payroll and benefits, and bring in an HR team for the work that needs a person.

Large and multi-state (500+)

You likely have HR staff already. We back them up on payroll, leave, compliance across states and big projects like leaving a PEO, without a per-employee fee on the whole workforce.

Before you sign

Questions to ask any provider.

  • Who is the employer of record for our staff?
  • Do we keep our own payroll system and benefit plans?
  • How are we billed in a month we need little help?
  • What does it take to leave, and how long is the agreement?
  • Who do we call, and will it be the same person each time?
  • Is help available outside business hours?

When someone else is the better fit

  • If you have a very small team and the main goal is benefit pricing from a large group plan, a PEO may still be the better fit.
  • If you need workers' comp and benefits bundled under one master contract and do not want to manage your own plans, a PEO is built for that.

Common questions

Can you help us leave our PEO?

Yes. Leaving a PEO means setting up your own payroll account, tax accounts and benefit plans. We plan the move, coordinate with your new payroll provider and broker, and test payroll before the first live run.

Will we lose our benefits if we leave a PEO?

You move from the PEO's plans to plans in your own company's name. We work with your broker to compare options and coordinate enrollment and payroll deductions so the change is clear to employees.

Are you cheaper than a PEO?

For most employers who do not need HR help every week, yes. A PEO charges per employee every month for as long as you stay. We bill only for the hours we spend, and a quiet month has no hourly bill.

Do you co-employ our staff?

No. You stay the only employer. We work alongside your team in your systems under a simple service agreement.

Free 15-minute call

Want a straight answer for your situation?

  1. Free 15-minute callTell us what is going on. You will get honest feedback on what to fix first, even if you never hire us.
  2. A clear scopeWe put the plan, the team and the hourly rate in writing before any work starts.
  3. Ongoing supportYour HR and payroll team takes it from there. Scale hours up or down whenever you need.