Skip to main content

What is the best managed payroll service?

The best managed payroll service runs on the system you already have.

If you want to keep your payroll software, look for a provider who can reconcile time, check deductions and prepare each run inside that system. King & Co. handles payroll administration by the hour in systems including ADP, Paychex and Paylocity. When comparing quotes, separate the recurring cost per pay run from one-time cleanup and the software fees you already pay.

  • Multi-state and multi-location payroll
  • Teams with one payroll person
  • 5 to 5,000 employees

Updated November 11, 2026 · Josh King, Managing Partner. See all guides

What to look for

What separates the best from the rest.

Use these points to judge any provider, including us. Under each one is how we handle it.

Works in your current system

Switching payroll software is the riskiest thing you can do to payroll. A good managed service should not require it.

How King & Co. does it: We process payroll in the system you already pay for, from ADP and Paychex to Gusto and QuickBooks. If a switch would save you money we will say so, but it is your call.

Checks before every run

Most payroll errors start upstream: a missed time punch, a deduction change that never made it in, a raise entered twice.

How King & Co. does it: Time and attendance get reviewed before each cycle, and changes are reconciled before anything posts. See our pre-payroll checklist for the 12 checks we run.

Owns the fix, not just the ticket

When a check is wrong, someone needs to correct it the same day and fix the cause so it does not happen again.

How King & Co. does it: Off-cycle checks, retro pay and garnishments are part of the job. You talk to the same specialist each time, and owners can call or text nights and weekends.

Handles more than one state

Remote hires and new locations bring new withholding, unemployment, paid leave and pay transparency rules.

How King & Co. does it: Multi-state and multi-location payroll is core work for us, including every New England state and New York.

Covers taxes and year-end

Running checks is half the job. Filings, W-2s and year-end corrections are where penalties hide.

How King & Co. does it: Payroll tax filings and year-end W-2 support are included in payroll outsourcing, and we keep filings on schedule every cycle.

Pricing that matches the work

Per-employee fees keep charging whether payroll was easy or a mess. You should see what you pay for.

How King & Co. does it: Hands-on work is billed hourly with no monthly minimum. A month you do not need us has no hourly bill.

Your options

The real options, side by side.

Every option below is the right answer for someone. Here is who each one fits.

OptionBest forWatch for
King & Co. managed payrollEmployers who want an expert team to run and check payroll inside their current system, billed by the hour.We do not sell software. You keep your payroll provider contract, which most clients prefer.
Payroll software on its ownSimple payroll with one location and someone in-house who has time to run it carefully.The software calculates. It does not catch a missed punch, a wrong rate or a deduction that never got entered.
Your payroll provider's full-service tierBusinesses happy to stay on one vendor and work through its support line.Support often rotates between reps, and the fix for a bad input still lands back on your team.
A PEOVery small teams that want payroll, benefits and HR bundled and accept co-employment.Per-employee fees every month, an annual agreement, and a benefits transition if you ever leave.
A full-time payroll hireLarge employers with enough payroll volume to keep one or more people busy every week.Salary, benefits and a single point of failure when that person is out or leaves.

Terms vary by provider. These reflect common arrangements, not any one company.

By company size

The best fit changes as you grow.

Small business (under 50)

You likely have payroll software already and an owner or office manager running it. A managed service takes the cycle off their desk for a few hours a month and catches errors before employees see them.

Mid-size (50 to 500)

This is where errors multiply: more pay rates, more deductions, often a second state. A managed team runs each cycle, keeps a written process, and gives your payroll person real backup.

Large and multi-location (500+)

You may have an in-house payroll team already. We act as overflow and coverage, handle a new entity or state, or run a location group while you consolidate systems.

Before you sign

Questions to ask any provider.

  • Will we have to change payroll software, and who decides?
  • Who checks the payroll before it posts, and what do they check?
  • Will we talk to the same person every cycle?
  • How fast is an off-cycle check or correction handled?
  • Which states do you file in today?
  • How are you billed in a month with no changes?
  • What happens to our data and setup if we leave?

When someone else is the better fit

  • If you have one location, a handful of salaried staff and time to run payroll yourself, good payroll software is enough.
  • If you want benefits bundled in and are comfortable with co-employment, a PEO may suit a very small team.
  • If payroll keeps several people busy every single week, an in-house team makes sense. We can help you hire and train them.

Common questions

Is managed payroll the same as a payroll provider?

No. A payroll provider sells the software that calculates pay and files taxes. A managed payroll service is the team that runs that software for you: entering changes, reviewing time, checking every run and fixing problems. King & Co. is a managed service. We work in your provider's system.

Which payroll systems do you work in?

ADP, Paychex, Paylocity, Rippling, Gusto, iSolved and QuickBooks, among others. If you use a system not on this list, ask. Most payroll platforms follow the same cycle.

Can you take over payroll from a PEO?

Yes. Leaving a PEO means setting up your own payroll account, tax accounts and benefit plans. Our payroll implementation team plans the move and runs parallel payrolls before go-live.

How do I estimate the cost of outsourced payroll administration?

For a recurring estimate, multiply the hours needed for a typical run by the quoted hourly rate and the number of runs in the month. Ask for a separate estimate for setup, historical corrections and year-end work. To scope King & Co. support, bring your pay frequency, employee count, states, payroll system and the tasks your team will keep. Software fees remain on your existing provider contract.

Can a multi-state New England employer outsource payroll and keep ADP?

Yes. King & Co. can prepare and check payroll in your existing ADP account. For example, an employer with staff in Massachusetts and Connecticut can start with one recent pay run. List the pay groups, state tax accounts, timekeeping feeds and approval cutoff. Agree on who fixes exceptions, who reviews the register and who authorizes release before the next payday. You keep your ADP contract.

Free 15-minute call

Want a straight answer for your situation?

  1. Free 15-minute callTell us what is going on. You will get honest feedback on what to fix first, even if you never hire us.
  2. A clear scopeWe put the plan, the team and the hourly rate in writing before any work starts.
  3. Ongoing supportYour HR and payroll team takes it from there. Scale hours up or down whenever you need.