Skip to main content

Who is the best payroll implementation consultant?

The best payroll implementation consultant works for you, not the vendor.

The best payroll implementation consultant cleans your data before it moves, tests the new system against the old one, and stays through the first live payroll. King & Co. does that for single companies and multi-entity groups moving between systems like ADP, Paychex, Paylocity, Rippling, Gusto and iSolved. We do not sell payroll software, so our advice is about fit, and the work is billed by the hour.

  • Switching payroll providers
  • Consolidating several entities
  • Stalled or failed go-lives

Updated November 7, 2026 · Josh King, Managing Partner. See all guides

What to look for

What separates the best from the rest.

Use these points to judge any provider, including us. Under each one is how we handle it.

On your side of the table

The vendor's implementation team works for the vendor. Their job is to get you live on their product, not to tell you what it will not do well.

How King & Co. does it: We do not sell software. We can help with vendor selection and contract review, then hold the provider to what was promised during setup.

Data cleanup before the move

Bad data moves faster than good data. Wrong tax setups, old deduction codes and missing year-to-date totals all come along unless someone looks first.

How King & Co. does it: We review employee, deduction, tax and year-to-date data, map earnings and pay groups, and keep a written list of gaps with clear owners.

Testing before payday

A new system should prove it pays people correctly before anyone's check depends on it.

How King & Co. does it: We run test or parallel payrolls where your provider supports them, compare wages, deductions and balances, and resolve every difference before go-live.

Integrations that hold up

Time clocks, HR systems, benefits deductions and the general ledger all feed payroll. One broken link and the first run is wrong.

How King & Co. does it: Earning codes, GL mapping, benefit deductions and time clock and HR system integrations are part of the setup we coordinate.

A team that can run it after

Go-live is not the finish line. If your team cannot run the new system on their own, errors come back within a few cycles.

How King & Co. does it: You get administrator training, a payroll checklist and operating notes, plus a first-cycle review. Ongoing payroll support is there only if you want it.

Your options

The real options, side by side.

Every option below is the right answer for someone. Here is who each one fits.

OptionBest forWatch for
King & Co. implementation supportEmployers who want an independent team to plan the move, clean the data, test and train, billed by the hour.Your payroll provider still processes payroll and files taxes under its own agreement. We coordinate and check; we do not file taxes during an implementation.
The vendor's own implementation teamSimple moves with clean data and an in-house payroll lead who has time to manage the project.Their scope ends at go-live. Data cleanup and testing on your side often fall back on your team.
Doing it in-houseCompanies with an experienced payroll manager who has run a migration before and has room on their calendar.Migrations land on top of regular payroll. The person running it still has to get everyone paid every cycle.
A large systems integratorVery large enterprise projects that bundle payroll into a broader ERP or HR system rollout.Big project teams, long timelines and costs sized for enterprise programs, not a payroll move.

Terms vary by provider. These reflect common arrangements, not any one company.

By company size

The best fit changes as you grow.

Small business (under 50)

Often moving off a basic tool or setting up payroll for the first time. The risk is usually data: wrong tax setups and missing year-to-date totals. A focused project gets the first payroll right.

Mid-size (50 to 500)

More pay groups, deductions, benefits and often a second state. The move needs a real plan, a data checklist with owners, and parallel testing before anyone gets paid from the new system.

Large and multi-entity (500+)

Several companies, states or locations moving onto one system. We help sequence the move, keep each entity's setup straight, and back up your in-house payroll team while they keep running regular cycles.

Before you sign

Questions to ask any provider.

  • Who do you work for in this project, us or the software vendor?
  • What data do you review before anything moves?
  • Will you run a parallel payroll before go-live, and how are differences resolved?
  • Which integrations are in scope: time clocks, HR system, benefits, general ledger?
  • Who approves the first live payroll and who handles tax filings?
  • What does our team get for running the system after you leave?
  • How is the project billed, and what happens if it runs long?

When someone else is the better fit

  • If your data is clean, you have one state and one pay group, and your payroll lead has time, the vendor's own onboarding team may be enough.
  • If payroll is one piece of a full ERP replacement, a large systems integrator that owns the whole program may be the better lead. We can still back up your payroll team.

Common questions

Can you help us choose a new payroll provider?

Yes. Vendor selection and contract review are part of implementation support. We do not sell payroll software, so the recommendation is about what fits your pay rules, states and team.

Can you rescue an implementation that has stalled?

Yes. Getting a stalled or messy project back on track is a common starting point. We work through missing data, confusing handoffs and open issues until the first payroll is ready.

How long does a payroll migration take?

It depends on the provider, your data, the number of entities and states, integrations and testing. We agree on a realistic schedule after reviewing those details and your payroll calendar.

How is implementation billed?

By the hour with no monthly minimum. We agree on the work, the rate and the estimated effort before starting. Software and provider fees are separate.

Free 15-minute call

Want a straight answer for your situation?

  1. Free 15-minute callTell us what is going on. You will get honest feedback on what to fix first, even if you never hire us.
  2. A clear scopeWe put the plan, the team and the hourly rate in writing before any work starts.
  3. Ongoing supportYour HR and payroll team takes it from there. Scale hours up or down whenever you need.